RAID 5 vs RAID 6 comes down to one extra parity drive: RAID 5 survives one drive failure and gives more usable space, while RAID 6 survives two drive failures at the cost of one more drive of capacity and slower writes. Choose RAID 6 for large drives and important data, and RAID 5 for smaller arrays where capacity and write speed matter more and you have solid backups.
Key takeaways
- RAID 5 uses striping with single distributed parity, needs at least 3 drives and tolerates 1 drive failure.
- RAID 6 uses striping with double distributed parity, needs at least 4 drives and tolerates 2 drive failures.
- Usable capacity is (n minus 1) drives for RAID 5 and (n minus 2) drives for RAID 6.
- RAID 6 has a higher write penalty than RAID 5, but similar read performance.
- Large drives take long to rebuild, which raises the risk of a second failure, so RAID 6 is the safer pick for big arrays.
- No RAID level replaces backups.
What is RAID 5?
RAID 5 spreads data and one set of parity information across all drives in the array. If one drive fails, the controller rebuilds the missing data from the remaining data and parity. It needs at least three drives, and the usable capacity equals the total of all drives minus one drive. It offers good read speed and efficient use of space, which is why it has been popular in small servers and NAS devices.
What is RAID 6?
RAID 6 works like RAID 5 but stores two independent sets of parity, so the array survives any two simultaneous drive failures. It needs at least four drives, and usable capacity equals the total minus two drives. The extra parity makes writes slower and uses more controller resources, but it greatly reduces the chance of losing the array during a rebuild.
RAID 5 vs RAID 6: how do they compare?
The table summarizes the main differences.
| Feature | RAID 5 | RAID 6 |
|---|---|---|
| Parity | Single distributed parity | Double distributed parity |
| Minimum drives | 3 | 4 |
| Drive failures tolerated | 1 | 2 |
| Usable capacity | (n minus 1) drives | (n minus 2) drives |
| Read performance | Good | Good, similar to RAID 5 |
| Write performance | Moderate, with a write penalty of 4 | Lower, with a write penalty of 6 |
| Rebuild risk | Higher, a second failure during rebuild loses data | Lower, it can survive a second failure |
| Best for | Small arrays, read-heavy data, backed-up workloads | Large arrays, large drives, critical data |
The write penalty is the number of disk operations needed for one small write. RAID 5 reads the old data and old parity and writes the new data and new parity, which is 4 operations. RAID 6 does the same with two parity blocks, which is 6 operations. Caches and full-stripe writes reduce the impact in practice.
How much usable space do you get?
RAID 5 gives you one drive less than the total, and RAID 6 gives you two less. For six 8 TB drives, the raw capacity is 48 TB, RAID 5 provides 40 TB and RAID 6 provides 32 TB. The chart shows the difference.
As the array grows, the share lost to parity shrinks. With 12 drives, RAID 6 uses only 2 of 12 drives for parity.
Why is RAID 6 safer with large drives?
RAID 6 is safer with large drives because rebuilds take longer and the chance of hitting a read error or a second failure during the rebuild grows. In RAID 5, the array is unprotected while it rebuilds, and one unreadable sector or another failing drive can cause data loss. In RAID 6, the second parity can cover that second problem. Drives bought together often come from the same batch and age together, which can raise the chance of nearby failures.
When should you choose RAID 5?
Choose RAID 5 when you have a small array, modest drive sizes, mostly read workloads and good backups. Examples include a small office file share, a media library or a lab server where capacity matters and you can restore from backup. RAID 5 also suits arrays with hot spare drives that start rebuilding right after a failure.
When should you choose RAID 6?
Choose RAID 6 when data is important, drives are large or the array has many drives. It is a good fit for archives, large NAS systems, virtualization storage and any system where a long rebuild would put the business at risk. If write speed is critical, consider RAID 10 or a hybrid level such as RAID 50, described in our guide to RAID 50. For a simple two-drive setup, see RAID 1 mirroring.
How do you choose between RAID 5 and RAID 6?
To choose, follow these steps:
- Count your drives. RAID 5 needs 3 or more and RAID 6 needs 4 or more. With 4 drives, RAID 6 leaves only half the raw space, so also consider RAID 10.
- Check drive size. The larger the drives, the stronger the case for RAID 6.
- Rate the data. If downtime or loss would hurt the business, choose RAID 6.
- Check workload. Write-heavy workloads favor RAID 10 over both parity levels.
- Plan spares and monitoring. Use hot spares, track drive health and replace failing drives early.
- Plan backups. Keep tested backups and a recovery plan whichever level you choose, as covered in our BC/DR guide.
If you move arrays between sites, use our data center migration checklist, and read about high availability for designs that survive more than a drive failure.
Frequently asked questions
Is RAID 6 better than RAID 5?
RAID 6 is safer because it survives two drive failures, but it uses more capacity and has slower writes. RAID 5 is better when you need more space or faster writes and have solid backups.
How many drives do I need for RAID 6?
You need at least four drives. Six or more is common, because the share of capacity used for parity gets smaller as the array grows.
Is RAID 5 still safe to use?
It can be, for small arrays with smaller drives and good backups. For large drives, many administrators prefer RAID 6 because of the long rebuild times and the risk of a second failure.
Is RAID a backup?
No. RAID protects against drive failure, not against deletion, corruption, ransomware or site loss. Keep separate backups using the 3-2-1 rule.
What is the difference between RAID 6 and RAID 10?
RAID 10 mirrors and stripes, with faster writes and quick rebuilds, but it uses half the raw capacity. RAID 6 uses less capacity for protection but has slower writes.
Conclusion
Pick RAID 5 for small, read-heavy arrays with good backups, and RAID 6 when drives are large and the data matters. Whichever you choose, use hot spares, monitor drive health and keep tested backups, because RAID only protects against drive failure.